أخلاقيات الاستعداد والاستجابة لجائحة كورونا عند بروس جينينجس الإشكاليات الأخلاقية والحلول العملية

نوع المستند : المقالة الأصلية

المؤلف

قسم الفلسفة، کلية الآداب، جامعه الفيوم

المستخلص

ناقش بروس جينينجس أصل جائحة كورونا واعتبرها جائحة صحية وحالة طوارئ صحية عالمية ، ورأى أنها ترجع إلى التدهور البيئي ؛ واستبعد سيناريو الإرهاب البيولوجي. وحاول ايجاد الحلول الفلسفية النظرية متمثلة في التأكيد على دور كل من الفلسفة والأخلاق المحوري وتقديم المبادئ الأخلاقية التي يجب أن يسترشد بها صُناع القرار في السياسات الصحية . وتكمن الاستجابة العملية في وجود استجابة وقائية تقليدية تتمثل في شكل تدابير أبوية وقائية واحترازية مثل تدابير التباعد الاجتماعي والحجر الصحي الطوعي والالزامي ، وتكمن الاستجابة التكنولوجية التقنية في الحلول الرقمية مثل مراقبة الهاتف المحمول ، وتكمن التدابير الصيدلانية العلاجية في فرض اللقاح وتخصيص الموارد الصحية .
كما درس بروس جينينجس المعضلات الأخلاقية العديدة التي تنجم عن تلك الاستجابات (الوقائية التقليدية و التكنولوجية والصيدلانية) ، وحاول تقديم الحلول الأخلاقية لها من أجل الوصول الى مرحلة العدالة الصحية ، رافضا اللجوء إلى المنهج النفعي  أثناء إدارة أزمة كورونا ، كما قدم دفاع أخلاقي عن أخلاق الفضيلة والواجب .
Abstract
Bruce Jennings discussed the origin of the Corona pandemic and considered it a health pandemic and a global health emergency, and saw that it was due to environmental degradation; He ruled out the scenario of bioterrorism. He tried to find theoretical philosophical solutions represented in emphasizing the pivotal role of philosophy and ethics and presenting ethical principles that should guide decision makers in health policies. The practical response lies in the presence of a traditional preventive response in the form of preventive and precautionary parental measures such as social distancing measures and voluntary and mandatory quarantine, and the technical technological response lies in digital solutions such as mobile phone monitoring, and therapeutic pharmaceutical measures lie in imposing the vaccine and allocating health resources.
     Bruce Jennings also studied the many ethical dilemmas that result from these responses (traditional, technological and pharmaceutical preventive), and tried to provide ethical solutions to them in order to reach the stage of health justice, refusing to resort to the utilitarian approach during the management of the Corona crisis, and presented a moral defense of the ethics of Virtue and duty.  

الكلمات الرئيسية

الموضوعات الرئيسية


أولًا :قائمة مصادر بروس جينينجس
(1) مؤلفات بروس جينينجس الفردية والمشتركة
 (1)- Jennings, Bruce et al (1998): The Perversion of Autonomy: the Proper Uses of Coercion and Constraints in a Liberal Society, 1 st edition .
(2)- Jennings, Bruce (2003): the perversion of Autonomy: Coercion and Constraint in A Liberal Society, Georgetown University Press.
(3)- Jennings, Bruce (2003): on Authority and Rational in Public Health, Vanderbilt University
(4)- Jennings, Bruce (2006): Ethics and Public Health: Model Curriculum, Hastings Center, And University of Washington.
(5)- Jennings, Bruces et al (2006): Public Health Ethics: Theory, Policy, and Practice, Oxford University Press.
(6)- Jennings, Bruce (2007): Public Health and Civic Republication, in A .  Dawson, prevention and Public Health, Oxford,  Oxford University Press.
(7)- Jennings, Bruce (2007): Community in Public Health Ethics, Oxford University Press
(8)- Jennings, Bruce et al (2008):  Ethical Guidance for public Health Emergency, Preparedness and Response, Highlighting Ethics and value in a vital Public Health
(9)- Jennings, Bruce (2013): The Hastings – Center Guidelines for Decisions in Life – Sustains Treatment and Care Near the End of Life: Revised and Expanded, 2nd Edition.
(10)- Jennings, Bruce (2014): Hospice Ethics, Policy and Practice in Palliative Care, Oxford University Press.
(11)- Jennings, Bruce (2016): Ecological Governance: Toward a New Social Contract with the Earth, 1 st edition, West Virginia University Press.
(12)- Jennings, Bruce (2016): Ethical Aspects of Public Health Emergency, Preparedness and Response, Oxford University Press.
(13)- Bruce Jennings, John D. Arras, Drue H. Barrett (2016): Emergency Ethics: Public Health Preparedness and Response, Oxford University Press.
(14)- Jennings, Bruce et all (2020): Palliative care in the Covid -19 Pandemic. Briefing Note, Bio- ethical Principles , Practices and Recommendations Relevant to the Covid-19 Pandemic.
(2): مقالات بروس جينفيز الفلسفية
(1)- Jennings, Bruce (1983): The care of the terminally Ill: Morality and economics, New England Journal of Medicine 309 (24), 1490-1494.
(2)- Jennings, Bruce (1988): Special Supplement: Ethical challenges of chronic illness, the Hastings Report 18 (1): pp,1-16.
(3)-  Jennings, Bruce (1991): The Regulation of Virtue: Cross-currents in professional ethics, Journal of Business Ethics, Vol10, Issue 8 , p, 562.
(4)-  Jennings, Bruce (2002): Ethics and Public Health: forging a strong Relationship, American Journal of public Health, New York, USA, 92 (2):169-170.
(5)- Jennings, Bruce (2003): on Authority and Justification in Public Health, Florida Law Review, 55(5), pp, 1241-1242.
(6)- Jennings, Bruce (2003): Frameworks for Ethics in public Health, Bioethics, 9(2):151.
(7)- Jennings, Bruce (2005): Dependency, difference and the global ethics of long-term care, the Journal of Political philosophy 13 (4): 443-469.
(8)- Jennings, Bruce (2007): Introduction: Ethical theory and public Health, Public Health Ethics, Theory, Policy, and Practice.
(9)-  Jennings, Bruce et al (2010): Access to hospice Care: Expanding boundaries, overcoming Barriers, Palliative Care: Transforming the care of serious illness 13 , 159-160.
(10)- Jennings, Bruce (2012): The place of solidarity in public health ethics, Public Health Review 34 (1), 4.
(11)- Jennings, Bruce (2015): Solidarity in the moral imagination of Bioethics, Hastings Center Report 45 (5):31-38.
(12)- Jennings, Bruce (2016):  Re conceptualizing Autonomy: A Relational Turn in Bioethics, Hastings Centers Report 46 (3): pp,11-16.
(13)- Jennings, Bruce (2020): Beyond the covid Crisis – New Social Contract With Public Health Hastings Bioethics Forum, Pandemic Planning, and Public Health, pp, 116-121.
(14)- Bruce Jennings, Daniel Callahan (2002): Ethics and Public Health: Forging a strong Relationship, American Journal of Public Health, 92 (2) : 169-176.
ثانيًا :المصادر باللغة الأجنبية :
(1)- المراجع باللغة العربية
عادل ضاهر (1990): الأخلاق والعقل ، نقد الفلسفة الغربية ، الطبعة الأولى ، دار الشروق للنشر والتوزيع ، عمان – الأردن .
فريدريك نيتشه (2007): هكذا تكلم ذرادشت ، ترجمة على مصباح ، منشورات الحمل ، ط1 ، بغداد.   
 (2)-  المراجع باللغة الانجليزية
(1)- Agamben, Giorgio (2015): State of Exception, Chicago, University of Chicago Press.
(2)- Arras, John (2015): Methods in Bioethics, the way we Reason Now, 1 Edition, Oxford, Oxford University Press.
(3)- Alfredo Morabia (2004) : A History of Epidemiologic Methods and Concepts, Discussion of the theories behind epidemiological methods
 (4)-  Bachelard , Gaston (2014): the Poetics of space ,Translated from the French by Maria  Jolas , 1958,Beacon Press , Boston. New York, United States of America.
(5)- Bellazzi, Francesca (2021): Covid -19 Calls for Virtue, Corona virus and Philosophy.
(6)- Beauchamp D. (1999): Community: the neglected tradition of public health .New York, Oxford University Press.
(7)- Beauchamp TL, Childress JF. (2001): Principle of Biomedical Ethics, 5 th ed , New York , Oxford University Press .
(8)- Callcott, J. Bard (1989): In Defense of the Land Ethics, Essays in Environmental Philosophy, New York.
(9)- Christian Coons, Michael Weber (2013): Paternalism: Theory and Practice, Cambridge University Press.
(10)- Conly, Sarah (2013): Against Autonomy, Justifying Coercive Paternalism, Cambridge University Press.
(11)- Coughlin, S. Steven (2009): Ethics in Epidemiology, Public Health Practice, second Edition, the American Public Health Association.
(12)- Coughlin, Stevens. (2021): Ethics, Epidemiology, Oxford University Press, New York, ch7.
(13)- Daniels N. (2008): Just Health, Meeting Health Needs Fairly, Cambridge, UK, Cambridge University Press.
(14)- Dowdle Wr , Cochi Sl  (2011) : Disease Eradication in the 21 st Century: Implications for Global Health, Cambridge, Massachusetts institute of Technology Press.
(15)- Faden Ruth., Powers Madison (2006): Social Justice, the  Moral Foundations of Public Health and Health Policy, biomedical ethics,1st edition, Oxford University Press .
(16)- Foucault, Michel (2008): The Birth of Bio politics, Lectures at the college de france 1978-1979, Edited by Michel Senellart , Palgrave Macmillan , translated by GRAHAM BURCHELL.
 (17)-  Holmen, Ralston (2011) : A New Environmental Ethics, The Next Millennium for life on Earth , Rutledge.
(18)-  Huntjens, Patrick (2021): Towards a Natural Social Contract, Healthy and Just Society, and Transformative Social – Ecological Innovation for a Sustainable, Healthy and Just Society.
(19)- Kakuk , P. (ed ) (2017): Bioethics and Bio politics, Theories, Applications and Connections, Cham, Cambridge University press. Springer
(20)- Lawrence O. Gostin (2018) : Public Health Law and Ethics, University of California Press.
(21)- Locke, John: second treatise of Simms, Karri: the concepts of Common Good Government and Public interest.
(22)- M, John Stuart (2015): Representative Government, Considerations on Representative Government, Create space independent publishing.
(23)- Max wall Smith and Ross Upshur (2019): Pandemic Disease, Public Health and Ethics, the Oxford Hand Books of Public Health
(24)- Murphy, Timothy (1994): Ethics in an Epidemic, Aids, Morality and Culture, University of California Press, London.
(25)- Rebecca joy (2020): Pandemic Vs Epidemic: What is the Difference?, Coronaviruses by the WHO, 2020   .
(26)- Richard Dicker: Principles of Epidemiology in Public Health Practice, 3 Editions, Introduction of Applied Epidemiology and Biostatistics   .
(27)- Ralston. H (1988): Environmental Ethics, Duties and Values in the Natural World Temple University Press.
(28)- Schwartz , Meredith Celene (2020): The Ethics of Pandemics , Moral Respect , Objectification and Health care, Broadview press , an independent publisher in the humanities since. 
(29)- Schwartz, Meredith Celene (2020): The Ethics of Pandemic, Planning and Response, 1 st Edition, Ryerson University.
(30)-  Sfetcu  , Nicolae (2021): Covid -19 Pandemic, Philosophical Approaches , Essays Collection  Multimedia Publishing.
(31)- Singer, Peter (2011): Practical Ethics, Cambridge University Press.
(32)-  T.M. Scanlon (2000) : What We Owe to Each Other, Harvard University Press.
(33)- Wilson, James (2014): the Ethics in an Epidemic Aids, Morality and Culture, from the ethics of disease eradication, University College London. United Kingdom.
(34)- Wilson, James (2016): Internal and External Validity in Thought Experiments, the WOBURN Suite –Senate House, University of London.
(35)- Willam D. Ross (2002) : The Right and the Good, Clarendon Press, Oxford.
المقالات باللغة الإنجليزية (3)
(1)- Abshur, Ross (2003): Quarantine Ethics, Journal Ethics, 5(11), p, 393.
(2)- Alex Dubov , Steven Shoptawb (2020): The Value and Ethics of Using Technology to Contain the Covid -19 Epidemic.
(3)- Andrew Park and et al (2006): When is Quarantine A useful Control Strategy for Emerging infectious Diseases?, American Journal of Epidemiology, 163 (5) , 479-480.
(4)- Austin, W. Michael (2020): Ethics in A Pandemic, Ethics for Everyone.
(5)- Barrett (2013): Economic Consideration for the Eradication, endgame, Philos Trans, ROCB, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal society, p, 368
(6)- Barrett (2013) : Economic Consideration for the eradication , endgame , Philos Trans , RSoc ,  p, 368.
(7)- Bellazzi, Francesca (2021) :Covid -19 calls for virtue ethics , Corona virus and Philosophy ,University of Bristol , Journal of Law and the Bioscience. Journal of law and the Biosciences, pp, 5-6
(8)- Caldwell, Christopher (2020): Meet the Philosopher who is trying to explain the Pandemic, Giorgio Agamben criticizes the “techno-medical despotism of quarantines and closings”.
(9)- Callaghan, o Cristina (2020): Planetary Health and Covid-19: Environmental Degradation as the Origin of the Current Pandemic, Environmental Health, CORONAVIRUS, And ENERGING VIRUSES. 
  (10)- Curran, Randall (2020): Ethicist’s: Covid -15 Pandemic a wake –up call.
(11)- Caplan, Arther (2009): is disease Eradication Ethical, vole 373, issue 9682, pp, 2192.
(12)- C E Taylor, Fcults and ME Taylor (2011): Ethical Dilemmas in Current Planning for Polio eradication, Journal of Public Health.
(13)- Clara Calia , Corinne Reid (2020): Ethical Challenges in the Covid -19= a Toolkit for Supporting analysis and resolution .
(14)- Claudi Emerson, Peter Singer (2010): Is There an Ethical Obligation to Complete Polio Eradication.
(15)- F.Fenner A.Liu, Jeffrey B. Ulmer (2002): Ethical Issues for Vaccines and Immunization, Nature Review immunology, vol2, p, 291.
(16)- Francesca Bellazi  , Konrad V Boyne burg K (2020) : Covid -19 Calls for Virtue Ethics , Journal of Law and Bioscience , vol 7 , issue 1.
Francesca Bellazi , Konrad V Boyne burg K (2020) : Covid -19 Calls for Virtue Ethics , Journal of Law and Bioscience , vole 7 , issue 1.
(18)- Ronald M. Atlas, Margaret A. Somerville (2005): Ethics, A Weapon to Counter Bioterrorism, Vole 307, Issue 51717, pp., 1881- 1882
 (17)- Gostin, Lawrence (2007): General Justifications for Public Health Regulation, Public Health 121 (11): 829-834.
(18)- G. Lourdes Velazquez (2020): The role of Philosophy in the Pandemic era, Bioethics Update, 6(2): 99-100.
(19)- Graham, Jesse, Jonathan Haidt (2007): When Morality Opposes Justice, Social Justice Research, 20 (1) : 113.
(20)- H. Gown, M. Hoeri, D. E. Hoffmann et al (2020): Maryland’s Experience with the Covid-19, Surg : What didn’t , what Next, p,150.
(21)- H. A. M. J. Ten Have (2020): Sheltering at our Common Home, Journal of Bioethical Inquiry          
(22)-  J. Harris et al (1995): Is There Amoral Obligation not Infect Others?, BMJ, Nov 4 , 311(7014): 1215.
(23)- MJames C. Thomas (2002): A Code of Ethics for Public Health, A American journal of Public Health Ethics
(24)- Hopkins, Travis (2020): The Ethics of Social Distancing and Why it Doesn’t Rule out Protesting, Justin Weinberg, Philosophy Documentation Center
Hudlin, Charles Willis (2001): Ant paternalism and John Stuart Mill.
(25)- Humphreys, Joe (2020): Coronavirus: How can Philosophy help us in this time of crisis?
(26)- Ole Martin Moen, AKsel Branen Sterri (2020): the Ethics of Emergencies, Philosophical Studies, 2621.
(27)- Paulson, Steve (2020): Can Philosophy offer a Light in the Dark?.
(28)- Jankowski, Jane (2020): Ethical Standards in a Pandemic, Current and anticipated Ethical Dimensions of the Covid -19 Pandemic, Cleveland Clinic.
(29)- James Wilson, David Hunter (2010): Research Exceptionalism, the American Journal of Bioethics, Vol 10, Issue 8, 36: 45-46  
(30)- Jeffery B Ulmer, Margaret A.Liu (2002): Ethical Issues for Vaccines and immunization, Nature Reviews immunology, Vol2,  pp, 291-292.
(31)- J Harris et al (1995): Is There Amoral Obligation not Infect Others, 4 (311) :PP,1215-1216.
(32)- Jonathan D . Moreno et al (2012): Efficacy is Relative in a Public Health Crisis: Evaluating, the Next Wave of Covid -19 Vaccines.
(33)- Jonathan D. Moreno, Arthur L. Caplan (2003): In the Wake of Terror: Medicine and Morality in a time of Crisis, Basic Bioethics
(34)- Jonathan Moreno and Arthur Caplan (2020) : Covid -19: Weapon , Accident or an administration gone batty?, The American Journal of Bioethics
(35)- Min W. Fong and et al (2020) : No pharmaceutical Measures for Pandemic influenza in Non Health Care Settings – Social Distancing Measures, volume 26 , Number 5 ,Policy Review Centers for Disease Control and Preventior ,CDC, Emerging Infectious Diseases . ext Wave of Covid – 19 Vaccines , Global Health, Hasting Bioethics
(36)- Kass E Nancy (2001): An Ethics Framework for Public Health, A American Journal of Public Health , 1776-1777.
(37)- K. Wynia , Matthew (2007): Ethics and Public Health , Emergencies : Restrictions on Liberty , The American Journal of Bioethics, 7 (2), 1-2.
(38)- Lawernce O. Gostin  and Matthew K Wynia (2004): Ethical challenges in Preparing for Bioterrorism : Barriers Within the Health care system , Journal of Public Health ,94(7) : 1096-1097.
(39)- Matteo Antonio Sacco et al (2020): The Impact of the Covid -19 pandemic on domestic violence: The dark side of home isolation, Medico –Legal Journal, Vol. 88(2) 71-72.
(40)- Manfred Max Bergman (2020) : The World After Covid World 1 (1), 45. University of  Basel , Switzerland               .
(41)- Max Well J. Smith , Diegosisilva (2020): Social Distancing , Social Justice and Risk During The Covid -19 Pandemic , Candia Journal of Public Health , 111(4), 459-460.
(42)- McCullough, Laurence (2013): Ethical Issues in Pandemic influenza Planning, WHO.
(43)- Michael Plant and Peter Singer (2020): When Will the Pandemic Cure be worse than Disease?, Business Fights Poverty .
(44)- Min W .Fong and et al : Non pharmaceuti ceutical Measures for Pandemic influenza in No healthcare Setting – social Distancing Measures.
(45)- Nancy E. Kass, Ss D (2001): Public Health Ethics Framework: A Guide for use in Response to the covid-19 Pandemic in Canada, American Journal of Public Health , American Public health Association,91 (11): 1776-1777.
(46)- Ole Martin Moen, AKsel Braanen Sterri (2020): the Ethics of Emergencies, Philosophical Studies, 2621.
(47)- Petre, Klepac, C. Jessica (2012): Towards the endgame and beyond: complexities and Challenges for the Elimination of infectious Disease, Philosophical Transactions of The Royal Society.
(48)- Peter Singer, Claudia Emerson (2010): Is There an Ethical Obligation to Complete Polio Eradication, Plume Metrics, 17,375 (9723) : 1340- 1341.
(49)- Peter, Michael. A(2020): Love and Social Distancing in the Time of Covid-19, the philosophy and Literature of Pandemics pp, 755-756.
(50)-  Reignier , Gean  et al (2020): Ethical Dilemmas Due to the Covid-19 Pandemic, Annals of Intensive Care , 10(84) 
(51)- Ronald M. Atlas, Margaret A. Somerville (2005): Ethics, A Weapon to Counter Bioterrorism, Vole 307, Issue 51717, pp, 1881- 1882   .
(52)- Sara Allan et al (2004): Making Decisions on Public Health, A review of eight countries, altering individual behaviors and life styles.
 (53)-  Susan H. Day (2020): Teaching Ethics, A structured Cubiculum on Ethics for ophthalmology Residents is Valuable 120 (7):963.
(54)- S. Barrett (2013 ): Economic Consideration for the Eradication, endgame, Philos Trans, ROCB, p, 368 .
(55)- Thompson, M. Kimberly (2007): Eradication versus control for Poliomyelitis: An Economic analysis, 1363.
(56)- Thomas Douglas, Hannah Maslen, Alberto Giubilini (2018): Developing World Bioethics 18 (2), 182-183.
(57)- Van Leeuwen et al (2019): The Psychology of Morality, Review, 23 (4): 363.
(58)- Weiner, Eric (2020): Philosophy for A time of Crisis, from Socrates to Camus, thinkers has asked how to respond when adversity turns our lives upside down. The  Wall Street Journal.
 (59)- Wilson, James (2014): the Ethics of Disease Eradication, Vole 32, issue 52, London, pp, 7179 -7180.
(60)- Wilson, James (2016):Vll- Internal and External Validity in Thought Experiments, Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 116 (2) : 134-135.
(61)- Wilson, James (2020): Corona Virus, Stay at Home, the Philosophy of Public Health from Coronavirus to the Neglectful State.
(62)- James Wilson, David Hunter (2010): Research Exceptionalism, the American Journal of Bioethics, Vol10, Issue 8, 36: 45-46.
ثالثًا : القواميس والمعاجم الفلسفية باللغة الإنجليزية
(1)- Doris, John, Stich, Stephen (2008): Moral Psychology, the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Stanford University.
(2)- Wallace, R. Jay (2007): Moral Psychology, the Oxford Handbook of Contemporary Philosophy, OUP Oxford, pp, 88.
(3)- Dictionary of Epidemiology (6th ed) (2014): New York: Oxford University Press 
(4)- Maxwall Smith and Ross Upshur (2019): Pandemic Disease, Public Health and Ethics, the Oxford Hand Books of Public Health.
(5)- Principles of Epidemiology in Public Health Practice, 3 Editions, Introduction of Applied Epidemiology and Bioethicists, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2016.
(6)-  Martin : Law and Public Policy , international Encyclopedia of Public Health.World Health Organization, Healthy at home.
(7)- Selgedid, Michael J (2012): Atale of Two Studies, Ethics, Bioterrorism and the censorship of science, Oxford Handbooks Research Reviews.
 (8)- Last J. A Dictionary of Epidemiology, 4th ed Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2001. (91).